2020 Craigslist Rental Scams
[Published 5/5/20; Updated below: 9/12/20] On May 15 a woman sent us a link to a Penthouse Condo for rent that was posted on Craigslist. She asked…. Did we think this was legitimate? It wasn’t! But it was also one of the best rental scams we have seen…
Here are the scammer signs we saw in this listing…
- We find the detailed information listed as very odd. For example, why list the type of Air conditioning as “Carrier Infiniti Series HVAC”. Most people will just say “air conditioning” or something simple. It is an odd laundry list of things but says nothing about the neighborhood yet they say “Generous Shower w/ Curb-less Entry, Frameless Glass Enclosed Shower”. What the heck is curb-less entry anyway?
- Most importantly, is the email address the “seller” has listed. In two locations he has specifically made an effort to post a personal email address in a way that goes against the Craigslist policy. Craigslist provides an anonymous email service to those who list and visitors must use the “Reply” button in the upper left corner to do so. (A phone number is permissible to be listed.) But rather than use the contact link that Craigslist provides, and can monitor, he separates his email address with spaces to get past the Craigslist filters: listed by: john.holmesrentals @ outlook . com
- The email address written by the person listing the property suggests he represents “John Holmes Rentals.” We Googled “John Holmes Rentals” and found a well-known realtor in the DC area with that name. So WHY is this man not using his business email address with a realty firm? Instead he has created a generic email at Gmail! This makes this listing EXTREMELY SUSPICIOUS!
We sprang into action and created a fictitious email account for a woman we named “Mary” and contacted Mr. “John Holmes” to inquire about his property. During this email exchange we tricked this scammer to reveal his location in the world. We weren’t the least bit surprised by what we discovered! Here is our email exchange with Mr. “John Holmes” and all the details of his scam….
I am very interested in the Penthouse you have listed on Craigslist.
Is it still available and if so, can I arrange to see it?
I need you to send me the link to the rentals so I can follow up with the corresponding details.
TDS NOTE: This is troubling because it suggests that “John” has multiple scam listings! We used the Google “site” command to search Craigslist.org for his email address and found another listing in Washington, DC as 1201 Q Street with his email address. (Into Google search field we typed: “site:craigslist.org john.holmesrentals” (without quotes) Here is the other scam listing posted by Mr. Holmes (click to enlarge):
Thanks for your quick reply. I am referring to this post….
Thanks for your interest in renting the property. Lease term is flexible, could be as short as 2 months or as long as one year with option to renew at the end of the one year term.
You’d get the very best of service, prompt response to issues, excellent customer service and a comfortable stay throughout your term. And most importantly, fast and easy leasing process with little or no hassle.
Though the unit originally comes fully furnished, however it can be rented either as furnished, semi furnished or unfurnished depending on tenants preference. Do note that the rent price remains unchanged irrespective of your choice. Pet friendly unit.
Details of the unit:
1. Monthly rent: 4000 (utilities like water, heat, AC, WiFi, electricity, parking and gas are included)
2. Security Deposit: $4000
3. Area (sq.Ft): 1850
4. No of Bedroom: 3
5. No of Bath: 2.5
6. Apartment: 2139 N St Nw #4 WASHINGTON, DC 20037
When exactly do you intend to move in and for how long are you looking to lease the unit?
We are interested in at least a year lease. It is for my fiance and me.
We would like to move in on June 1 if possible. Is it?
Could we see the apartment this weekend? Saturday or Sunday work for us.
The unit is currently still being occupied at this time, however it would be vacated by 05/24. We have been receiving quiet a huge number of emails from prospective tenants but the landlord has not been very comfortable with with what we have so far. I’m a bit selective (NOT discriminating) in accepting a suitable responsible tenant.
Therefore we have set up an online questionnaire of basic questions a landlord would ask anyone interested in renting his/her property and also as a form of screening applicants. There are no credit cards or payment required.
Fill out the rental application form on the link below;
TDS Note: Legitimate realtors will never use a generic Google form for an application! They will use a written form or a form on their legitimate realty website. If the scammer’s Google form disappears or you would prefer not to click it, here is what it looked like…. Page 1 and 2:
I just filled out the form John.
We look forward to hearing from you and hope to see the property soon. Can we see it on May 24th?
After a careful review of all the application received so far, we are please to inform you that your application has been accepted tenancy and I trust you will take good care of the unit during your stay.
TDS NOTE: Notice that Mary is being pressured to make a down payment without even having a phone conversation or seeing the apartment!
That’s wonderful! Thank you! What do we need to do now to secure it?
I’ve filled out the application but when I try to make a deposit I get an error saying that this Chase Account has been closed for security reasons. This is what I see: [LINK REDACTED]
I’m sorry, is there another account I should use?
Mr. “John Holmes” of Washington, DC clicked the link we sent him and revealed that he is a Nigerian scammer from Asaba, Nigeria:
UPDATE to this scam 5/18/20: We didn’t respond to “Mr. Holmes” once we learned that he was from Nigeria. However, 2 days later he sent us another email to tell us that we could send our deposit to his Bank of America account! We have notified the FBI, Chase Bank and Bank of America of all these details.
On May 4 we were contacted by a woman who had just avoided a scam listed as a house rental on Craigslist. The home for rent was listed as 5315 Hoboken Rd., Madison, WI 53713 by someone who identified himsel as “Mr. Ron Steve and Family, Project Manager for Garmong Construction.” This is, of course, all a lie. Mr. Ron Steve used the phone number 413-312-1758.
We had no problem locating that property on Zillow.com. It was listed for rent at $1650, much higher than what Mr. Ron Steve had been asking ($850). This is common for rental scams! They lure people to them by lower than market value rents. (Click images to enlarge.)
The “Rent Questionnaire” was also suspicious because it asked questions that shouldn’t be asked or in a way that was very suspicious. Questions from Mr. Ron Steve included….
1. Date of Birth
2. Reasons for Leaving
3. Are you married
4. Do you have a car
5. How soon can you have the deposit and rent payment sent to me
6. How soon do you want to receive the keys
7. Your Family Pictures [TDS NOTE: As in “please attach family pictures.” Seriously??]
Mr. Ron Steve claimed to work for Garmong Construction. However, what he did was stole the photo of a man named Ron H. from the Garmong Construction website that appears when you mouse-over the formal picture of Ron dressed in a suit. (We are excluding that photo from this story since the real Ron is easily identified.)
After sending in the “Rent Questionnaire” with their answers, the woman was immediately informed that the home was hers to rent! All she had to do was wire money to the scammer!
IMPORTANT NOTE ABOUT THESE SCAMS:
1. In each of these apartment scams, the listed price is well below the local market value. No doubt, this is meant to be the incentive to attract potential victims!
2. The person who owns the apartment is always in some distant state and unable to show it personally. This sham is now legitimized during the COVID pandemic and actually seems reasonable but NO REAL PERSON WILL EMAIL YOU THE KEY TO THEIR PROPERTY after exchanging a few emails!
3. The listing often (but not always) has limited photos of the apartment, especially the interior.
4. Communication with the “owner” is always via email or text, and he or she is not available by phone, and especially not via video chat!
5. The English in these exchanges is often poor and awkward indicating that it is not the person’s first language.
[UPDATE September 12, 2020] On September 12, a woman informed us that she was offered an apartment for rent by John Holmes and asked to fill out an application using a generic Google form like those above. Here is the email from John Holmes:
In the Google form application, this scammer asked the following questions below. Notice that he ENTICES victims to pay him MORE money up front by offering a discount on the rent. NO ONE DOES THIS IN REAL LIFE!
1. Address Of Property You Are Applying To
2. Desired Move-In Date
3. Number of Occupants
4. Disired Lease Length
5. Co-applicant names (If Any)
6. Full name, email, phone and current address
7. Present employer
8. Have you ever been convicted of a crime?
9. Have you ever filed for bankruptcy?
10. Have you owned a home in the past?
11. Have you ever been evitected from a tenancy or left owing money?
12. Are you a United States Veteran?
13. Are you moving in with a pet? (Provide details)
14. If you eventually get selected, which of these payment plans would you opt for?
a) Month to month rent payment with 0% discount
b) 3 moths rent and get a discount of 10% off the monthly rent
c) 6 months rent payment and get a discount of 15% off the monthly rent
d) One year rent payment and get a discount of 25% off the monthly rent
15. Is there anything else we should know that could increase your chance?
The Closing paragraph says:
Authorization: I hereby apply to lease this rental property and I warrant that all statements above set forth are true.I hereby give my permission to communicate with my current and former landlord(s) or property manager(s) for the purpose of discussing any and all of the facts and circumstances of my current or former tenancy, as well as the other information listed above. I am aware that a credit history, landlord/tenant court search and criminal background check may be done in conjunction with my application and I hereby authorize the property manager to request the aforementioned reports. TYPING MY FULL NAME BELOW QUALIFIES AS MY SIGNATURE AS PER THE UNIFORM ELECTRONIC TRANSACTIONS ACT (UETA).
[UPDATE July 26, 2020] On Sunday, July 26, a woman looking for an apartment on Craigslist.com found an attractive four bedroom house listed at #40 Candleberry Dr, Queensbury, NY 12804. She reached out to the person who posted the Craigslist apartment, a man identified as Bryan Morgan, and got this reply:
On Sun, Jul 26, 2020 at 12:51 PM bryan morga <email@example.com> wrote:
Thanks for your email response. My house is still available for rent and the rent include utilities Electricity,heat,laundry facilities, Air condition, Internet and phone line. And I also want you to know that it was due to my work transfer that made me and my wife to leave the house with an intention of giving it out for rent.We are looking for a responsible person that can take very good care of it as we are not after the money for the rent but want the property to be kept clean all the time as it is our hard-earned property. If you are honestly interested and will absolutely maintain my property (Taking care of it like yours) as i hope i can put my trust and confidence in you.. Long and short lease available.
Presently, We are here in South Carolina doing the UNICEF program(The United Nations Children Fund) for through our direct service to mankind, the blessings and promises of God will manifest today. The house vital informative documents and the entrance keys to my house is with us, we try to look for dependable agent to handle the rent but could not find one due to the limited time we had before leaving the state. Mostly we do not want our property to be given to any sort of person to avoid damages and troubles. I and my wife came over to South Carolina for a missionary work, So we hope you will be a good tenant which we’ve been praying to get.
Rent: $1050 monthly include with utilities.
Refundable Security Deposit: $1050
The House is 4Bedrooms 2Bathrooms
The House Address is 40 Candleberry Dr, Queensbury, NY 12804
SO IF YOU ARE REALLY INTERESTED, FILL THE RENT APPLICATION FORM BELOW RENTAL APPLICATION DETAILS
FIRST NAME: __________________
MIDDLE NAME: __________________
LAST NAME: __________________
PHONE (____) __________ (WORK)
PHONE (____) __________ (CELL)
MARITAL STATUS: _________
KIDS _____ (YES/NO), HOW MANY ________
HOW MANY PEOPLE WILL BE LIVING______
PRESENT ADDRESS: ________________________
ZIP CODE: ____________
WHY ARE YOU LEAVING? ____________
YOUR CURRENT RENT: _______________
WHEN DO YOU INTEND MOVING IN? __________
PICTURES OF OCCUPANT SHOULD BE ATTACH
IF YOU HAVE A PET,
NAME OF PET: ______________
KIND OF PETS: _____________
DO YOU SMOKE? ______________
DO YOU DRINK? ______________
DO YOU WORK LATE NIGHT? ____
I ____________________CERTIFY that answers given herein are true and complete to the best of my knowledge. I authorize investigation of all statements contained in this application for tenant screening as may be necessary in arriving at a tenant decision. I understand that the landlord may terminate any rental agreement entered into for any misrepresentation made above.
Landing 22’1 “x 5’10” (6 .. 73m x 1.78m)
Kitchen 13’0 “x 11’0” (3.96M x 3.35 m)
Bedrooms 12’10 “x 10’5” (91M x 3.18M)
Bathroom 6’10 “x 5’10” (2.08m x 1.78m)
WC 5’0 “x 2’10” (1,52 m x 0,86 m).
Kindly get back to me as soon as possible.
Thanks And God Bless.
Bryan Morgan & Family
FIVE RED FLAGS THAT REVEAL THIS RESPONSE IS FRAUDULENT:
1. Critical readers will notice that the email address used by Bryan Morgan, is an odd misspelling of his name by dropping the last letter.
2. It is VERY CUSTOMARY of African scammers to end their email messages with words like “God Bless.”
3. Some of the questions asked by this landlord are inappropriate and ridiculous!
4. The details in the dimensions and names of the rooms are absolute giveaways that the email sender is not operating by the same naming standards and measurements that are customary in the United Sates.
5. No REAL landlord would EVER say “Presently, We are here in South Carolina doing the UNICEF program(The United Nations Children Fund) for through our direct service to mankind, the blessings and promises of God will manifest today. The house vital informative documents and the entrance keys to my house is with us, we try to look for dependable agent to handle the rent but could not find one due to the limited time we had before leaving the state.”
The woman who was interested in this property also noticed that the address was listed for sale on several realtor’s websites. She brought this to the attention of “Bryan Morgan” and his reply was “My initial plan is to sell the house but my wife and my lawyer advised me to rent it out.” The woman replied by expressing an interest to have Mr. Morgan’s agent show her the property, to which Bryan Morgan said “Listen to me. I have terminated the contract with the agent because I’m not selling my property anymore so I’m doing this myself.”
The woman, now very suspicious, replied with how interested she was to see the property and “I’m not sure I know of anyone who would ever rent a place without seeing it first. I’m sure you can understand.” But Bryan Morgan simply stated “I really understand how you feel. You can only go ahead and drive by the house to check it out.” This is 100% confirmation that “Bryan Morgan” is a scammer and doesn’t really own this property!